Replacing your home's siding is a significant decision, and with many options on the market, it's essential to choose wisely. Vinyl siding has been a popular choice since the 1960s and is renowned for its beauty, durability, and cost-effectiveness.
On the other hand, fiber cement provides better durability, rot resistance, and excellent fire resistance. These qualities make it a compelling alternative to wood siding. So, to help you determine the right siding for your home, our experts have prepared this practical guide on the main differences between vinyl and fiber cement siding.
1. Vinyl vs. Fiber Cement Siding: The Composition
Fiber cement siding is a blend of Portland cement and wood pulp. It is shaped into wood-like boards and nailed directly to your house. Vinyl siding, on the other hand, is made from thin PVC panels or strips. Its unique construction allows it to adapt to temperature changes by expanding and contracting.
2. Vinyl vs. Fiber Cement Siding: Appearance
Regarding the appearance of your home's siding, vinyl siding provides a broader range of colors and finishes. It also can mimic various natural siding materials such as wood boards and cedar shingles.
On the contrary, fiber cement siding is specifically designed to resemble wood. So, it has a nearly identical wood-like appearance. While fiber cement has limited pre-painted options, it can be painted in any color. So, it is easier to upgrade your home’s color and style in the future compared to vinyl siding.
3. Vinyl vs. Fiber Cement Siding: Durability
Regarding durability, both vinyl siding and fiber cement siding are excellent choices. Fiber cement siding is quite complex, but it is susceptible to cracking and chipping because it is a cement-based product. It can also absorb moisture and may cause issues in the future.
Conversely, vinyl siding is entirely waterproof and highly resistant to cracking and chipping. It surpasses fiber cement boards in impact resistance. However, if subjected to significant force, it is not wholly immune to punctures.
4. Vinyl vs. Fiber Cement Siding: Ease of Installation
For siding installation, vinyl is the easier option. Its lightweight nature makes handling a breeze compared to fiber cement. Remember, avoid nailing it tightly against the house during any siding installation to prevent warping due to temperature changes. Leave some gaps for proper movement and overlap side-to-side to allow your siding to "breathe."
Fiber cement boards, however, are heavy and need at least two individuals for installation. Secondly, you must be careful of the dust when cutting fiber cement, as it poses health risks. The boards are nailed tight to the house during installation. Ultimately, hiring professionals is the simplest way to handle siding installation.
5. Vinyl vs. Fiber Cement Siding: Fire Resistance
To enhance fire resistance in your home, opting for fire-retardant materials is crucial. When comparing vinyl siding and wood, vinyl is prone to melting, while wood is flammable. Fiber cement has much better fire resistance than both vinyl and wood. Its composition makes it highly fire-resistant, making it superior to housing siding materials.
Due to its plastic nature, vinyl siding can melt in extreme heat or long-term sun exposure, leading to warping. Remember that appliances such as a BBQ grill installed near the vinyl siding can easily damage it, either melting or discoloring it.
6. Vinyl vs. Fiber Cement Siding: Maintenance Requirements
Regarding maintenance requirements, vinyl is easier and more convenient to maintain. Fiber cement requires immediate painting upon installation due to its porous nature, and caulking is necessary in all corners and seams to prevent water seepage.
Over time, paint fades, and caulk deteriorates. So, it requires constant re-caulking or repainting to maintain its appearance and integrity. In contrast, you can clean and maintain your vinyl siding using a brush and a garden hose. So, you can preserve its original condition with minimal effort for years.
How To Choose and Install the Best Siding for Your Home?
For more information, you can reach Watkins Construction & Roofing at 601-488-3179. We service areas in Jackson, Flowood, Clinton, and Ridgeland, MS.